5 Things I Learned Moving From a Big Church to a Small Church

Split image contrasting a large church worship service on the left with a smaller, quieter church sanctuary on the right, with bold white text across the top reading, "5 THINGS I LEARNED MOVING FROM A BIG CHURCH TO A SMALL CHURCH".

A few years ago, I left my big church of 1,500 people as a kids pastor to become an executive pastor on my way to being a lead pastor. The church I stepped into was around 100. Within a month my head was spinning because it felt like a completely different world. At that point, I’d been in ministry for 15 years. I thought I knew how churches worked. But my experience was limited to churches between 400 and 1,500. How you do church changes when you work with that many people. (I could write another post about going from 400 to 1,500, but that’s not for today.)

In this week’s post, I’ll share 5 things I learned in the transition.

1. Recruiting is harder

I’ve written many volunteer recruiting posts and I still stand by them no matter what size church you’re in. However, in a small church there’s just a much smaller pool to recruit from. Instead of having 30 potential parent volunteers, you have 3, and two of them are on the worship team.

In addition, at my large church we had four different services when I started, one on Saturday, two on Sunday, and one on Wednesday. At most churches of 100 or fewer, you only have one service. Therefore the mantra “work one, worship one” doesn’t work. At a large church, a potential volunteer has multiple options to serve and still go to church. At a small church they’re choosing to miss their service to serve. I know we should all serve willingly, but when you’re recruiting new people, the idea of missing service is too much of an obstacle for them.

While recruiting is harder, I have found a far higher proportion of dedicated volunteers. It’s a lot easier to find a volunteer to step up and serve literally every week, faithfully making service happen for only 3 or 4 kids. I call these volunteer owners.

At the big church, I could count the owners on one hand. It’s way easier to sell the big lights, big crowds, and multiple options to a new volunteer. But that also makes church feel more consumeristic, and once they’re not getting what they want, they’re out. They’re what I call renters. You need both on any team, but it’s easier to find a renter at a big church than a small one.

2. Excellence is negotiable

Coming from Megachurch world, excellence was a given, an expectation. When I was in ministry tech school, it was drilled into me. We serve with excellence in everything, from what goes on the screen and stage to the type of trash cans in each room.

But at a small church it’s not that way. It’s easy to find walls that need a little touch-up, graphics clearly made by an amateur, bulletin boards with Christmas cards from last year and it’s October. Excellence feels negotiable.

I don’t mean to criticize. Sunday, I was looking at a spot on a wall in my lobby that needs a touch-up and wondered if I had the right kind of paint to fix it. My point is that a large church can pay for professionals to make sure all that excellence happens. They have graphics people who went to college to learn how to use Photoshop. They have maintenance people whose only job is to make sure the trash is taken out and the paint is fresh. They have ministry leaders who pore over every document that gets posted and maintain their freshness and accuracy.

A small church can embrace excellence too. When I started doing the graphics for the first small church I worked for, the people were shocked. They had no idea you could put up an image that wasn’t pixelated and watermarked from Shutterstock. They hadn’t noticed there weren’t any trash cans in the lobby. They had no idea about the smell in the kitchen.

For a small church, the building is home. These people were born there. Their parents may have been born there. They were married and had kids there. So they treat the church like their house. They mean well, but they don’t see the chips.

A large church can feel that way too, but as I said before, there are people who are working to maintain excellence. Generally, people like to go to places that look like they were prepared for them. That’s why Disney can charge almost $200 a ticket to stand in the hot Florida sun for a day, but the little putt-putt place around the corner from you just closed because they couldn’t keep the weeds down.

I think that if you make excellence a priority, your guests will feel far more welcome. And your members will too.

3. Staff wears many, many hats

When I served at the Megachurch, I was paid full time to oversee the children’s ministry and that was it. But it was even more narrow than that. I had a part-time nursery coordinator who managed everything for kids 5 and under. The most I did for her was pick up snacks from Sam’s.

However, at a small church, you do way more than just one thing. At my current church, I’m the only full-time staff member. So today, I finished my sermon, worked on the church website, posted on social media, wrote an email, followed up with someone who signed up for baptism, worked with the music and kids volunteers on Christmas plans, and thought about the budget for next year. And today is not unusual.

When I tried to go outside my area at the Megachurch, they looked at me like I was crazy. When I went outside my area at the small church, they were thankful. Finally, someone is going to do it. One thing I’ve learned is that at a small church you need to be a jack of all trades. At a larger church you need to be a specialist.

So don’t look with envy at the person whose kids ministry has twice as many kids as your entire church. They’re focused on just one age group. They don’t have to make all the graphics, scrub the toilets, and repaint the walls. They have people for that. You get to serve in many more areas using your gifts and talents for more than just Sunday morning.

4. I know everyone

When I was at the Megachurch, unless you had elementary-aged kids, I didn’t know who you were. When I was at a church of 400, unless you had kids, I didn’t know who you were. Now that I’m at a church of 100, I know everyone. Granted, I’m the lead pastor. It’s kind of my job. But my kids pastor and youth pastor know everyone too. In my previous post, I mentioned I have a volunteer checking in everyone as they come through the door because he knows everyone. Drop that same volunteer into a church 15 times larger and that task becomes laughable.

There’s a sociological idea called Dunbar’s number. It basically means you can only maintain about 150 meaningful relationships at a time. Anyone outside of that becomes white noise. The principle holds in church world too. If you have a church of 70, it’s easy to know everyone and their cousin. At a church of 1,500, that’s near impossible.

From a discipleship perspective, this is ideal. It’s a lot easier to develop and maintain a relationship with everyone and not feel like I’m leaving anyone out. Because I’m not. At the Megachurch, we focused on small groups because that was the only way people were going to be cared for and discipled.

By contrast, my average size church is a small group. I’m still building a small group culture, so we’re prepared for growth, but the urgency isn’t there. It’s relatively easy for a person to get connected and stay connected outside the system.

5. People are people

One thing that hasn’t changed no matter how big a church I’m in is that people are people. A big church just has more of them. The pastoral skills I honed over 15 years of ministry still work. A hospital visit. A “we missed you” phone call. A handwritten birthday card. These are all just as effective at a small church as they are at a large church. There are still people far from God. Still people who need to know how to pray, study their Bible, and serve. Still people trying to figure out what to do with their life, their kids, and their marriage. That hasn’t changed and will never change.

God has placed you where you are for a reason, to serve the people you see every week, big church or small. Be faithful with the little and God will give you much. (Luke 16:10)

That said, I have to sign off from this post. Church starts soon and I have to go serve the people God has placed under my care.

Related Posts

Resources to Lead Well

Next
Next

Your Check-In System Is a Pastoral Care Tool